Carriage Tour Accidents in Downtown Charleston: Who Is Liable When a Horse-Drawn Carriage Causes Injury?

Horse-drawn carriage tours are one of downtown Charleston’s most iconic attractions. Every year, tens of thousands of tourists climb aboard open-air carriages for narrated rides through the historic district, passing antebellum homes, centuries-old churches, and cobblestone streets in the South of Broad neighborhood and beyond. But when a 1,800-pound draft horse shares narrow city streets with motor vehicles, cyclists, and pedestrians, the potential for serious injury is real.

According to the City of Charleston, carriage tour companies operate under a regulated permit system that limits routes, hours, and the number of carriages on the street at any given time. Despite these safeguards, carriage-related accidents continue to occur. Horses spook at loud noises, carriages collide with motor vehicles at intersections, passengers fall from carriage seats, and pedestrians are struck while crossing in front of moving carriages. When these accidents happen, the question of liability is rarely straightforward.

Charleston’s Horse-Drawn Carriage Tour Industry

Charleston’s carriage tour industry has operated for decades and is deeply embedded in the city’s tourism economy. Several licensed companies run tours through the historic district, departing from designated areas near the City Market and along North Market Street. Each carriage is pulled by draft horses or mules, and the large public carriages carry up to 16 passengers on bench-style seating without seatbelts, doors, or other restraints.

The carriages share roads with cars, trucks, delivery vehicles, tour buses, bicycles, pedicabs, and pedestrians. Routes pass through some of the most congested blocks in Charleston, including Meeting Street, Church Street, East Bay Street, and the narrow residential streets south of Broad Street. The combination of animal-powered transport, heavy motor vehicle traffic, and dense pedestrian activity creates an environment where accidents are not a matter of if but when.

Unlike a motor vehicle, a horse-drawn carriage cannot brake instantly, cannot swerve predictably, and is ultimately controlled by an animal with its own instincts. When something goes wrong, the consequences can be severe for passengers, pedestrians, and even drivers of nearby vehicles.

Common Types of Carriage Tour Accidents

Horse Spooking Incidents

Draft horses used for carriage tours are trained and conditioned for urban environments, but no amount of training can eliminate a prey animal’s flight instinct entirely. Horses can be spooked by car horns, backfiring engines, emergency vehicle sirens, fireworks, loose dogs, umbrellas opening suddenly, or unexpected movements from pedestrians. When a draft horse bolts, it can pull a fully loaded carriage into traffic, onto a sidewalk, or into a parked vehicle at considerable speed. Passengers seated on open benches with no restraints are thrown from the carriage or slammed against the wooden frame.

Carriage-Motor Vehicle Collisions

Carriages operate in mixed traffic on streets that were designed long before automobiles existed. Drivers unfamiliar with Charleston’s roads — particularly tourists — may not anticipate the slow speed of a carriage, may attempt to pass in a narrow lane, or may fail to yield when a carriage is turning. Rear-end collisions, sideswipe accidents, and intersection collisions involving carriages happen regularly. A car accident involving a carriage presents unique dynamics because the carriage offers no crash protection to passengers.

Passenger Falls

Carriage seating is elevated, open, and lacks seatbelts, guardrails, or enclosures. Passengers who lean out to take photographs, stand up during the ride, or lose balance when the carriage hits a pothole, makes a sharp turn, or jolts to a stop can fall to the pavement from a height of several feet. Asphalt, concrete curbs and granite curbstones make for an unforgiving landing surface.

Pedestrians Struck by Carriages

Downtown Charleston’s sidewalks are narrow, and pedestrians frequently walk in the street, especially in the South of Broad neighborhood where sidewalks are sometimes nonexistent. A pedestrian struck by a horse or carriage wheel can suffer crushing injuries, broken bones, or head trauma. Tourists unfamiliar with carriage routes may step into the street without looking for horse-drawn traffic.

Horse-Related Injuries at Boarding Areas

Passengers boarding or exiting carriages at staging areas can be bitten, kicked, or stepped on by the horse. Draft horses weigh between 1,600 and 2,200 pounds, and a single kick or step can fracture bones, cause internal injuries, or knock a person to the ground.

Who Is Liable When a Horse-Drawn Carriage Causes Injury?

Liability in a carriage tour accident can fall on one or more parties depending on the circumstances. South Carolina negligence law requires the injured person to show that a duty of care was owed, that duty was breached, and the breach caused the injury. In carriage accidents, multiple defendants are often involved.

The Carriage Tour Company

A carriage company that carries paying passengers may be held to the heightened standard South Carolina applies to common carriers — the highest degree of care, though not a guarantee of safety (Singletary v. Atlantic Coast Line R. Co., 1950). No South Carolina appellate court has decided whether a sightseeing carriage qualifies; at a minimum the company owes reasonable care. Under either standard, a tour company can be found negligent for failing to properly train drivers, failing to maintain carriages in safe condition, using a horse with a known history of spooking, overloading a carriage beyond its safe capacity, or failing to cancel tours during dangerous weather conditions. The company is also vicariously liable for the negligence of its employees — including carriage drivers — under the doctrine of respondeat superior.

The company may also invoke South Carolina’s Equine Activity Liability Act (S.C. Code §§ 47-9-710 to -730), which shields equine sponsors and professionals from liability to participants for the inherent risks of equine activity, such as a horse’s unpredictable reaction to sound or sudden movement. The Act’s definition includes “driving, or being a passenger upon an equine,” but no South Carolina appellate court has decided whether a carriage tour passenger is a “participant.” The Act does not protect a company that supplied faulty tack it knew or should have known about, failed to assess the participant’s ability, ignored a known latent dangerous condition on its premises, acted wilfully or wantonly, or intentionally caused the injury (§ 47-9-720(B)), and its protection is lost if the required warning sign or contract notice is missing (§ 47-9-730). It does not reach pedestrians and bystanders, who are not participants, or liability arising from the use of a motor vehicle.

The Carriage Driver

Drivers are responsible for controlling the horse, following designated routes, obeying traffic laws, warning passengers about safety precautions, and responding appropriately when a horse shows signs of agitation. A driver who is distracted, impaired, inexperienced, or who fails to react properly when a horse spooks can be personally liable. However, because drivers are typically employees of the tour company, claims are usually brought against the company rather than the driver individually.

The Horse Owner

In some cases, the horse used for carriage tours is owned by a third party and leased to the tour company. Under South Carolina’s animal liability principles, the owner of a domesticated animal can be liable for injuries caused by the animal if the owner knew or should have known of the animal’s dangerous propensities. If a horse has previously bolted, bitten, or kicked, the owner’s failure to disclose that history or retire the animal from service can establish liability. This applies to premises liability and animal owner liability theories.

The City of Charleston

The City of Charleston generally cannot be sued for how it regulates or permits the carriages (S.C. Code § 15-78-60(4), (12)), but it can be liable for a pothole or other road defect, a sign that was knocked down and not replaced, or a malfunctioning traffic signal that it knew or should have known about and failed to fix within a reasonable time (S.C. Code § 15-78-60(15)). It is not liable for road design. Claims against the City of Charleston are subject to the South Carolina Tort Claims Act (S.C. Code § 15-78-10 et seq.), which caps damages at $300,000 per person and $600,000 per occurrence, bars punitive damages (S.C. Code § 15-78-120), and cuts the filing deadline to two years (S.C. Code § 15-78-110), with an optional verified claim filed within one year extending it to three (S.C. Code § 15-78-80).

Third-Party Motor Vehicle Drivers

If a car, truck, or bus causes the carriage accident — by rear-ending the carriage, running a red light, or honking in a way that spooks the horse — the driver of that vehicle can be liable. A car accident in Charleston that triggers a chain reaction involving a carriage may distribute fault among the motor vehicle driver, the carriage company, and potentially other parties.

Charleston Carriage Tour Regulations

The City of Charleston maintains one of the most regulated carriage tour industries in the country. Key regulations in the city code include:

• Medallion limits — the city issues a fixed number of zone medallions (34), and a carriage cannot begin a gate tour without one, which caps the number of carriages touring at once
• Route restrictions — carriages are assigned to specific zones and routes through a lottery system at the start of each tour, preventing overcrowding on any single street; carriages may not use cobblestone or Belgian-block streets or the bricked portion of Church Street (Water Street to South Battery)
• Operating hours — gate tours through the residential historic district run from 9 a.m. to early evening (5 p.m. in winter, 6 p.m. in summer); evening rides are limited to the commercial district
• Heat limits — tours stop when the temperature reaches 95°F or the heat index reaches 110°F (four readings, 15 minutes apart), and any horse whose temperature reaches 103°F after a tour comes out of service to cool down
• Horse rest requirements — horses must receive mandatory rest periods between tours, and daily work hours are limited
• Driver competency — drivers must hold a driver’s license and pass a city competency exam on handling horses and carriages in emergencies, and companies must run city-approved annual training
• Equipment and inspections — carriages need an annual city certificate and required lighting and reflectors, and must be kept in safe condition; a carriage in an accident must be inspected before it returns to service
• Passenger capacity — each carriage has a maximum passenger count based on its size and the horse’s pulling capacity

Violations of these regulations can serve as strong evidence of negligence. If a tour company exceeded the passenger limit, operated during a heat restriction, or used a carriage that had failed inspection, those facts help establish that the company breached its duty of care. Under the legal doctrine of negligence per se, violating a safety rule designed to prevent the type of harm that occurred can establish negligence if the rule was meant to protect people in your position, though you must still prove the violation caused your injury (Whitlaw v. Kroger Co., 1991).

Injuries From Horse-Drawn Carriage Accidents

The lack of any crash protection on a horse-drawn carriage means that even a low-speed incident can produce serious injuries:

• Traumatic brain injuries — passengers ejected from a carriage or pedestrians struck by a horse can hit their head on pavement or curbs; concussions, skull fractures, and intracranial hemorrhages are common
• Spinal cord injuries — falls from carriage height onto hard surfaces can cause compression fractures, herniated discs, and in severe cases paralysis
• Broken bones — fractures of the hip, pelvis, wrist, arm, and ankle from falls or from being struck by the carriage or horse
• Crush injuries — a carriage wheel rolling over a pedestrian’s foot, leg, or body can cause devastating crush injuries requiring surgery or amputation
• Soft tissue injuries — sprains, strains, torn ligaments, and road rash from falls onto pavement
• Internal injuries — blunt force trauma from a horse kick or from being thrown against the carriage frame can cause organ damage and internal bleeding
• Wrongful death — in the most tragic cases, a runaway horse, a high-speed collision with a motor vehicle, or a severe head injury from a fall can be fatal

Elderly passengers and children are particularly vulnerable. Older adults are more likely to suffer hip fractures from falls, and children are more likely to fall from elevated, open seating. Head injuries in both groups carry higher risks of long-term disability.

South Carolina Comparative Fault Rules

South Carolina follows a modified comparative fault system. An injured person can recover damages as long as their own share of fault is less than 51%. If the injured person is found to be 51% or more at fault, they recover nothing. If found partially at fault below that threshold, the damages award is reduced by their percentage of fault.

In carriage accident cases, defendants commonly argue that the injured person contributed to their own injuries. Common comparative fault arguments include:

• The passenger was standing up, leaning out, or not following the driver’s safety instructions
• The pedestrian was jaywalking, looking at a phone, or walking in a carriage lane
• The passenger was intoxicated and lost balance
• The injured person approached the horse despite warnings not to

These arguments do not eliminate the tour company’s liability — they only reduce the damages if the jury finds the injured person partially at fault. An experienced premises liability lawyer in Charleston can counter these arguments by focusing on any heightened duty the company owes as a carrier of paying passengers and the regulatory violations that contributed to the accident.

Filing Deadlines for Carriage Accident Claims

The statute of limitations for a Charleston carriage accident depends on who is sued:

• Tour company, driver, horse owner or motorist: 3 years from the date of injury (S.C. Code § 15-3-530)
• Claims against the City of Charleston or another government body: 2 years (S.C. Code § 15-78-110)

Claims against the City of Charleston under the South Carolina Tort Claims Act run on a shorter clock. The action must be commenced within two years of the date the loss was or should have been discovered (S.C. Code § 15-78-110) rather than the usual three. Filing a verified claim with the entity within one year (S.C. Code § 15-78-80) is optional and extends the deadline back to three years. Missing the two-year deadline can bar your claim entirely, regardless of how strong the underlying case may be.

Wrongful death claims have their own deadlines. In South Carolina, a wrongful death action must be filed within 3 years of the date of death (S.C. Code § 15-3-530(6)), or 2 years if a government body is a defendant, and it is brought by the personal representative of the estate (S.C. Code § 15-51-20).

Preserving Evidence After a Carriage Accident

Evidence in carriage accident cases can be difficult to preserve. Key steps include:

• Photograph everything — the carriage, the horse, the road conditions, your injuries, and the surrounding area
• Get the driver’s name and the tour company name — the guide must wear an ID, and the carriage must carry its insurance carrier and policy number
• Identify witnesses — other passengers, pedestrians, and nearby shop owners may have seen what happened
• Request surveillance footage — many businesses on carriage routes have exterior cameras; this footage is often overwritten within days
• Obtain the police report — if law enforcement responded, request a copy of the incident report from the Charleston Police Department, and ask for the written accident report the driver or guide must file with the city’s Livability & Tourism office within 24 hours
• Seek medical attention immediately — even if injuries seem minor, get examined; delayed symptoms are common with head injuries, spinal injuries, and internal bleeding
• Do not sign anything from the tour company — do not sign waivers, releases, or accept settlement offers before consulting an attorney

Tour companies are aware that evidence disappears quickly. An attorney can send preservation letters to the tour company, the city, and nearby businesses to prevent the destruction of carriage maintenance records, driver training files, horse veterinary records, and surveillance footage.

How a Charleston Personal Injury Lawyer Can Help

Carriage tour accident cases involve legal theories that most personal injury claims do not. A possible common carrier standard, the Equine Activity Liability Act defense, animal liability doctrines, city regulatory compliance, and potential government tort claims add layers that require experience with Charleston’s specific carriage industry.

A lawyer handling a carriage accident claim will:

• Investigate the tour company’s safety record, including prior incidents, regulatory violations, and inspection history
• Obtain the horse’s veterinary and behavioral records to determine if the animal had known dangerous propensities
• Review the carriage driver’s training records, licensing, and employment history
• Examine whether the city maintained safe road conditions on the carriage route
• Retain accident reconstruction and equine behavior experts if needed
• Calculate the full value of your damages, including medical expenses, lost wages, pain and suffering, and long-term disability
• Negotiate with the tour company’s insurance carrier and, if necessary, take the case to trial in Charleston County Circuit Court

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I sue a carriage tour company if I signed a waiver before the ride?

Waivers and liability releases are not always enforceable in South Carolina. Courts read waivers strictly against the company that wrote them, will not apply one to the company’s own negligence unless it says so clearly, and void releases so broad they would excuse the company for any reason (McCune v. Myrtle Beach Indoor Shooting Range, 2005; Fisher v. Stevens, 2003). Many waivers also exclude gross negligence by their own terms, and the Equine Activity Liability Act does not protect wilful or wanton conduct. If the tour company operated with reckless disregard for passenger safety, a signed waiver may not bar your claim.

What if the carriage accident was caused by another driver who honked and spooked the horse?

Multiple parties can share liability. The motor vehicle driver may be liable for causing the horse to spook, and the tour company may also be liable if the horse was insufficiently trained for urban conditions or if the driver failed to control the animal. South Carolina allows claims against all responsible parties.

Are carriage tour companies required to carry insurance?

Yes. The City of Charleston requires carriage tour companies to carry liability insurance at least equal to South Carolina’s auto minimums ($25,000 per person / $50,000 per accident) plus $5,000 in medical-payments coverage, as a condition of each carriage’s city certificate. This insurance provides a source of recovery for injured passengers and bystanders.

What compensation can I recover after a carriage tour accident?

You may recover medical expenses (past and future), lost wages and earning capacity, pain and suffering, emotional distress, disfigurement, and loss of enjoyment of life. In wrongful death cases, the family may recover funeral expenses, loss of financial support, and loss of companionship.

How long does a carriage accident case take to resolve?

Many cases resolve within several months to a year or two through settlement negotiations. Cases involving disputed liability, severe injuries, or government defendants may take longer and could require trial. Your attorney will advise on the expected timeline based on the specific facts of your case.

What if I was a pedestrian struck by a carriage, not a passenger?

Pedestrians have the same right to pursue a claim against the tour company, the carriage driver, and any other responsible parties. Any heightened carrier duty applies primarily to passengers, but the tour company still owes pedestrians a duty of ordinary care to operate safely on public streets. Pedestrians and bystanders are also outside the Equine Activity Liability Act, which applies only to participants.

Do I need to report a carriage accident to the police?

Yes. Call the Charleston Police Department to report the incident. A police report creates an official record of the accident, documents the parties involved, and may include the responding officer’s observations about fault, road conditions, and regulatory compliance.

If you or a loved one was injured in a horse-drawn carriage accident in downtown Charleston, the personal injury attorneys at Roden Law can evaluate your case at no cost. We handle carriage accident claims on a contingency fee basis — you pay nothing unless we recover compensation for you. Call our Charleston office at (843) 790-8999 or our firm-wide line at 1-844-RESULTS for a free consultation.

About the Author

Graeham C. Gillin

Partner, COO